So, it was not long after arriving on campus just a few months ago (Aug ’11), before I had been a part of several conversations about how great it would be if there was a pub on-campus. There were stories that there used to be something of the sort in the basement of the refectory, but whatever traces remained of it (I believe it was shut down about a decade ago) were entirely gone in the wake of the re-modelling that took place there the previous spring. Some of the returning students had been brain-storming possible locations for a future pub, but nothing had come to any fruition. But then one fateful morning, I was sitting with Dr. Klukas (Dean of admissions, wife of Fr. Klukas, professor), who, when I brought up something about a pub on campus, off-handedly mentioned that there used to be one in the basement of the Fort (one of the old, large houses on campus, called “The Fort” because of its fortess-like lime-stone construction).
Thrilled that there might be something still down there – right there under our noses but unknown to anyone – we left the refectory immediately to go check it out. What we found was a mixed bag: Very little remained of what once might have been there: only a pool table, and a few pictures and paintings on the walls. There was no furniture, no bar, just a dirty, boarded-up basement with a bunch of garbage in a pile in the middle, and about 1/8” of dust covering everything. There was, however, beneath the garbage, a ‘U’ shaped piece of wood with a support screwed into the back – the old bar-top! And – there were these sconces on the pillars, still with candles in them, and above them were painted several diocesan crests. It was this vestige of an old pub that gave us the ‘vision’ for what the space could be oncemore. That is – there was just enough for us to catch a vision of what the place could be. Someone mentioned the “Prancing Pony” from Lord of the Rings and we were hooked. We tried to to deduce when exactly the ‘Pub’ became extinct – the longest professor here (Kucharski) has no memory of it (and he’s been here 20 years), but then there is the banner by the fire-place that reads ‘Class of 2006′. However, the diocesan-crests painted on the pillars have a sort of 70′s styling. Our best guess is that it was a pub in the 70s, and then faded into obscurity (or was shut-down), and then in the early 2000s a small group of students used the space for cards or something – but it wasn’t a full-blown pub at that time.
And so, the task of resurrecting it:
Lars Skoglund, Aaron Zook, Evan Simington and myself emerged and came together as being ones who wanted to do the work of re-establishing the place, and so we set to work: cleaning up mountains of dirt, dust and cobwebs, moving out all the trash, then designing and building a bar (we used the original ‘U’-top beneath the ‘J’ design that we came up with), then salvaging furniture from various attics and basments on campus (including sweet c. 1960′s Dept. of Defense drinking water barrels – in case of nuclear fall out – which we set up as stools). I started a “Founders Club” so that we could get funds to continue with the project (since, we had already spent about $200 at Home Depot) – that is – anyone who wanted to see a Pub get realized on campus: give me $30 and you’ll get a mug with your name on it once its open.
The support was overwhelming – I collected more than $900 (of which we spent all but $20). Another major boost in our morale that we might actually pull this off was when a board-member who was on campus for convocation (Fr. Koehler), when we told him about the idea, immediately volunteered to buy the ‘kegerator’ (the fridge/tap unit that keeps and pours the beer) for us – a purchase that was going to cost us hundreds of dollars, and we didn’t know if we could afford. But when that arrived, we knew we hadto make it work. And so – neglecting sleep and studies during the week that followed convocation, Lars, Zook, myself, and a handful of other generous souls here and there put our noses to the grindstone.
After dozens of hours putting on finishing touches (painting the A/C ducts brown to look like wood-beams, staining and finishing the bar, sanding off the finish and re-doing it all (turns out – lacquer can’t go on top of Polyurethane – who knew?), mopping, building shelves, hanging pictures and buying glasses, and finally – going out and buying our first two half-barrels of beer. We had promised to the community to open that weekend, and we managed to pull it off – and had a big opening-night hoop-la, which, in true Nashotah House fashion, included a procession from the chapel with a full Litany (including all the patron saints of brewing – there are 14! again, who knew?!)
and then a blessing of the space followed by, yup, you guessed it – lots of beer! And pool, and pizza, and laughing and pats on the back. The Cellar was (and is!) open! For all to enjoy – like a student union (which space was lacking on campus prior), or one of the pubs the various Oxbridge colleges have.

The Rules
As for the name – we tried several things on – but the simplicity of ‘The Cellar’ took quickly, and then it was Fr. Peay, who also had long-time been wanting to see a pub around these parts, who suggested Gambrinus, who was a medieval king and patron of beer-brewing as a patron. Voila!














A Job Well Done and a much needed retreat during the long dark cold nights in The Kettle Moraine. Hoist one for me.
Unless Cindy B has beaten me to the honor, I hereby submit my $30 in hopes of becoming the first Lutheran charter member… otherwise I’ll settle for 2nd place.
Sorry I couldn’t be there for the blessing. I do hope that St. Katharine von Bora Luther, well known for her home brew that made the sainted Dr. Matin Luther’s Table Talks famous (or at least memorable), was included in the litany of patron saints of the keg. (If not, maybe we’ll just have to process again?!?!)
Ha! I can’t recall if Ms. Bora Luther was mentioned or not. And – I’ll be happy to take your money, but i don’t think we have any more founders’ glasses, sadly! sorry, Pastor Cathi! But I look forward to buying you a pint sometime
I’m going to have to come visit sometime! So cool
Thanks, man!
From the Dutch “Vrije KonijnenVogels” brewing community, we congratulate you and your affiliates with the creation of a fine place of, as the Germans would say, Gemütlichkeit!
your organization is an inspiration
Very Cool, looking forward to residency week next July.
Looks great! Nan and I will be back in January and will come and join you! Hope plenty of incense was used to properly consecrete the space.
you bet! we could hardly breathe!
I remember finding that pub my Junior year, 1989. It was in pretty good shape, but looked abandoned even then. Have fun!
During my recent visit to The Mission for “Experience Nashotah”, I was extremely attracted to the idea of becoming part of the community, but it was the pub that really won me over. The fellowship of students and faculty as real members of community was a refreshing sight.
Congratulations! To take it to the next level, you definitely need to revive the monastic tradition of home-brewing. You can get starter equipment from Midwest Supplies in Minnesota if there isn’t a brewing store in the Milwaukee area. They also make kits that are very easy to use. Will be up there for Epiphany Term.
I LOVED the Pub! had a great time as we visited the House, and it was so much better to join the seminarians in Fellowship at “The Cellar”. You all remain in my prayers as Advent quickly approaches.
Faithfully,
Brandon+
All it needs to be a real pub is a couple of bottles of rye whiskey (Canadian)
Nice work. We wouldn’t have recoursed to the Sawyer’s Pub in town if we’d know that was in the fort for the fixing. Has the ghost turned up for a pint yet? I’ve never met him, but I know someone who moved out of the fort on the spot having done so.
Just found the posting of the new pub… well done… i love to see former youth group participant helping their community..i look forward to catching up with you…cheers
Mark Strong
The only thing missing is The Order of the Cellar which I will pay ($100 plus) to join for a name on the wall of members and my own initialled members mug.
The following gives specifity in defining a 4 pint limit (64 oz) from the old Angleish…
ein furst kold pint fer me tirst and di segund fer korporal qwenchin…di tird fur a rownd wit me fellas und di fort fer da gut nakt…Adieu! me gut wyf und supper und eben daly offis ist waitin!…
I am coming up to Experience Nashotah in 2 weeks and I am hoping one of you guys who resurrected the pub will let me Experience The Cellar with you!
Great name for a basement pub. I wonder if Deacon Denys Scully goes there for a pint now and then?